Take On Me Vs. As It Was: Which Song Reigns Supreme?

Hey music lovers! Let's dive into a fascinating musical debate: which song reigns supreme – "Take On Me" by A-ha or "As It Was" by Harry Styles? Both tracks have captivated audiences globally, but they offer distinct sonic landscapes and evoke different emotional responses. This is a showdown for the ages, and we are going to dive deep into these two songs to find out why they’re so impactful, and ultimately, try and see which one is, dare I say… better? Okay, maybe “better” is subjective, but we can definitely break down their merits and see what makes them tick.

The Timeless Synth-Pop Anthem: "Take On Me"

"Take On Me," released by the Norwegian band A-ha in 1985, is more than just a song; it's a cultural phenomenon. This iconic synth-pop anthem is immediately recognizable by its distinctive opening keyboard riff and Morten Harket's soaring vocals. The song's energy is infectious, driven by a driving beat and layered synthesizers that create a sense of urgency and excitement. But what truly catapulted "Take On Me" into the stratosphere was its groundbreaking music video. The rotoscope animation, a blend of live-action and hand-drawn animation, was revolutionary for its time and remains visually stunning even today. This video wasn't just a visual accompaniment; it was an integral part of the song's identity, helping to tell a fantastical story of love and escape. The visuals perfectly complemented the song's lyrical themes of yearning and taking a chance on love, creating a complete and immersive experience for the viewer. Beyond its technical brilliance, the video resonated with audiences on an emotional level, solidifying "Take On Me" as a timeless classic. The impact of “Take On Me” stretches far beyond the 80s. It’s been featured in countless movies, TV shows, and commercials, constantly reminding us of its infectious energy. The song’s melody is instantly recognizable, and its enduring appeal speaks volumes about its quality and craftsmanship. The use of synthesizers, the powerful vocals, and the unique music video all combined to create something truly special – a song that continues to inspire and entertain generations.

"Take On Me" isn't just a catchy tune; it's a masterclass in songwriting and production. The song's structure is perfectly crafted, building anticipation with each verse and chorus. Harket's vocal performance is nothing short of breathtaking, showcasing his incredible range and emotional delivery. The lyrics, while simple, are effective in conveying a sense of longing and hope. The song’s themes of love and taking risks are universal, making it relatable to listeners of all ages and backgrounds. Musically, “Take On Me” is a standout track. The synth melodies are instantly memorable, and the driving beat makes you want to dance. But it's the combination of all these elements – the vocals, the lyrics, the music, and the iconic video – that makes "Take On Me" a true masterpiece. It’s a song that transcends genres and generations, and its place in music history is firmly secured.

Harry Styles' Nostalgic Ballad: "As It Was"

Fast forward to 2022, and we have Harry Styles' "As It Was," a song that dominated the charts and airwaves. "As It Was" is a different beast altogether compared to "Take On Me." While both songs are undeniably catchy, "As It Was" leans into a more melancholic and introspective vibe. The song's signature synth riff has a retro feel, reminiscent of 80s new wave, but it's layered with a contemporary pop sensibility. Styles' vocals are smooth and emotive, conveying a sense of longing and vulnerability. The lyrics delve into themes of change, distance, and the bittersweet nature of relationships. The opening spoken-word intro, featuring Styles' goddaughter Ruby Dymond saying "Come on, Harry, we wanna say goodnight to you!", adds a personal and intimate touch to the song. This small detail, seemingly simple, creates an immediate connection with the listener, drawing them into the song's world. It’s a reminder that even the biggest pop stars have personal lives and relationships, and it adds a layer of authenticity to the song. "As It Was" succeeds in creating a sense of intimacy despite its global success.

"As It Was" is a carefully constructed pop song, showcasing Styles' growth as a songwriter and artist. The production is sleek and modern, but it doesn't sacrifice the song's emotional core. The synth-driven melody is undeniably catchy, but it's also tinged with sadness. The lyrics are poetic and evocative, painting a picture of a relationship in flux. The song's themes of change and separation are relatable to many, and Styles delivers them with sincerity and vulnerability. The music video for "As It Was" is also visually striking, featuring Styles dancing in a circular motion on a revolving platform. The video's choreography and color palette complement the song's themes of movement and change, creating a cohesive artistic statement. The visual elements of the video, combined with the song's melancholic tone, create a powerful and moving experience for the viewer. The use of color, the fluidity of the movement, and the overall aesthetic all contribute to the song's emotional impact.

A Clash of Eras and Styles

So, how do these two songs stack up against each other? "Take On Me" is a burst of pure, unadulterated energy. It’s a song that makes you want to dance and sing along at the top of your lungs. Its optimism is infectious, and its iconic video has cemented its place in pop culture history. It's a feel-good anthem that continues to resonate with audiences across generations. On the other hand, "As It Was" is a more nuanced and introspective song. It's a song that makes you think and feel, and its melancholic melody lingers in your mind long after it's over. It's a testament to Styles' artistry and his ability to connect with listeners on a deeper level. The song’s themes of change and distance are particularly relevant in today’s world, where relationships are often challenged by geographical boundaries and personal growth.

Both songs utilize synthesizers prominently, but they do so in different ways. "Take On Me" uses synthesizers to create a bright, energetic soundscape, while "As It Was" uses them to create a more atmospheric and melancholic vibe. The tempos of the songs also differ significantly. "Take On Me" is fast-paced and upbeat, while "As It Was" has a more moderate tempo, allowing the listener to fully absorb the song's emotional nuances. Ultimately, the choice between "Take On Me" and "As It Was" is a matter of personal preference. There’s no objectively “better” song, as they both excel in different areas. "Take On Me" is a classic for a reason, a testament to the power of a great melody and innovative visuals. "As It Was" is a more contemporary offering, showcasing Styles' evolution as an artist and his ability to craft emotionally resonant pop songs. It’s a song that speaks to the complexities of modern relationships and the challenges of navigating change.

The Verdict: Two Timeless Tracks

In conclusion, both Take On Me and As It Was are incredible songs that have left a significant mark on the music landscape. "Take On Me" is a timeless synth-pop classic that embodies the spirit of the 80s, while "As It Was" is a modern pop masterpiece that showcases Harry Styles' artistic growth. Whether you prefer the energetic vibes of A-ha or the introspective melodies of Harry Styles, both songs offer a unique and rewarding listening experience. These songs are not just catchy tunes; they are snapshots of different eras and reflections of different emotional landscapes. They both resonate with listeners for different reasons, and their enduring popularity is a testament to their quality and artistry. So, instead of choosing a winner, let’s appreciate both songs for what they are: two timeless tracks that will continue to be enjoyed for years to come. What do you guys think? Which one do you lean towards, and why? Let’s get the discussion going!