John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes Rating: A Critical Misjudgment?

Pedro Alvarez

4 min read

Post on May 12, 2025

4.8

Share

The Discrepancy: Audience vs. Critics on Rotten Tomatoes

The difference between audience and critic scores on Rotten Tomatoes for John Wick: Chapter 4 is striking. While audience scores soared to a remarkable 98%, the critics' consensus languished at a comparatively lower score (around 89% at the time of writing – this number may fluctuate). This significant gap is not uncommon; often, audience and critic ratings diverge, indicating varying tastes and priorities. However, the sheer magnitude of the difference in this case suggests a potential misalignment in critical assessment.

• Specific Numbers: As mentioned, the audience score hovered around 98%, while the critics' score was significantly lower. This disparity warrants a closer look at the reasons behind this divide.
• Potential Reasons for Discrepancy: The reasons for this gap are multifaceted. Critics may focus on different aspects of filmmaking (narrative complexity, originality) compared to audiences (enjoyment, action sequences). This could account for the divergent scores, highlighting the subjective nature of film criticism.
• General Trend: It's worth acknowledging the general trend of audience scores often exceeding critic scores on Rotten Tomatoes, suggesting a possible preference for mainstream entertainment amongst the general public versus the potentially more niche perspectives of professional film critics.

Analyzing the Critics' Consensus: What Went Wrong?

Common criticisms leveled against John Wick: Chapter 4 on Rotten Tomatoes often centered on its perceived excessive length and formulaic plot points. Some critics argued that the film's runtime hindered its narrative momentum and that certain plot developments felt predictable within the established action genre.

• Main Negative Points: Critics pointed to the film's near three-hour runtime as a potential weakness, feeling it stretched the narrative thin in places. Some also criticized the arguably familiar tropes found within the plot, suggesting a lack of originality.
• Counterarguments & Strengths: However, these criticisms overlook the film's strengths. The extended runtime allows for more elaborate action sequences and deeper character exploration. The familiar elements provide a comforting framework for audiences already invested in the John Wick universe.
• Positive Reviews: Many positive reviews highlight the film's masterful execution of action sequences, compelling characters, and thrilling narrative payoff, directly contradicting some of the negative critiques. These counter-narratives demonstrate that a significant portion of critics did, in fact, appreciate the film's qualities.

The Action and Stunts: A Masterclass Underrated by Critics?

John Wick: Chapter 4 is undeniably a triumph of action cinema. The film's fight choreography is groundbreaking, seamlessly blending practical effects with CGI to create breathtakingly innovative and visually stunning sequences.

• Innovative Action Choreography: The innovative use of diverse fighting styles, locations, and weaponry elevates the action beyond the typical gun-fu spectacle. The film showcased a level of creative combat rarely seen on screen.
• Specific Praised Scenes: Scenes like the lengthy, single-take fight in the Parisian club and the climactic showdown showcase the sheer skill and precision of the filmmaking team. These moments are frequently cited by audiences as highlights.
• Technical Aspects: The technical prowess involved – from the camera work to the editing – ensures that the action remains both thrilling and comprehensible, even during its most complex sequences.

Beyond the Action: Character Development and Narrative

While the action is undeniably a cornerstone of the film, John Wick: Chapter 4 also succeeds in delivering compelling character development and a satisfying narrative arc.

• Character Development: John Wick's journey is further explored, providing depth and emotional resonance to the character. Supporting characters, too, receive significant development, adding emotional weight to the action.
• Narrative Structure: The film's narrative structure, while seemingly straightforward, is intricately woven, tying together the previous films while introducing compelling new elements. The payoff is satisfying, resolving lingering plot points and setting up future possibilities.
• Addressing Plot Complexity/Predictability: While certain plot points may be predictable within the established genre conventions, the film's execution and emotional impact elevate it beyond mere predictability.

Is John Wick 4 Truly Misjudged? A Call to Action

In conclusion, the significant disparity between audience and critic scores for John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes rating suggests a potential critical misjudgment. While some critics pointed to the film's length and perceived formulaic elements, these criticisms fail to adequately account for the film's masterful action choreography, compelling character development, and overall thrilling cinematic experience. The undeniable strengths of the film, especially its innovative action and satisfying narrative arc, far outweigh any perceived weaknesses. We urge you to form your own opinion. Watch John Wick: Chapter 4, check out both the audience and critics' scores on Rotten Tomatoes, and share your thoughts on John Wick 4's Rotten Tomatoes rating with us in the comments below! Let the world know if you agree with the critics or side with the overwhelming audience approval.