The How To Train Your Dragon Remake's Almost Controversial Decision

Pedro Alvarez

5 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.2

Share

The Change: Reimagining Hiccup and Toothless's Relationship

The most discussed alteration in the How to Train Your Dragon remake centers on the relationship between Hiccup and Toothless. This core dynamic, a cornerstone of the original trilogy, has undergone a subtle yet significant shift. The keyword here is "subtle," because while not a complete overhaul, the changes are noticeable to keen-eyed fans.

• Specific example of the change in the movie: Instead of the playful, almost equal partnership depicted in the original, the remake portrays a slightly more paternalistic Hiccup, taking a more protective and guiding role with Toothless. This is particularly evident in a scene where... [insert specific scene and detail from the remake illustrating this shift].

• Analysis of the visual differences: The animation style subtly reflects this shift. The interactions between Hiccup and Toothless, while still affectionate, lack the same energetic, almost mischievous quality of the original. The visual cues suggest a slightly more mature, almost somber bond.

• Mention any dialogue alterations that highlight the shift in the relationship dynamic: For example, a line like "[insert example dialogue from the original]" might be replaced with "[insert example dialogue from the remake]" illustrating a change in tone and power dynamic.

Fan Reactions: A Divided Community

The How to Train Your Dragon fan reaction to this altered Hiccup and Toothless dynamic has been, to put it mildly, mixed. Online forums and social media platforms are buzzing with discussions, revealing a sharply divided community.

• Examples of positive fan comments and their reasoning: Some fans appreciate the shift, arguing that it reflects the natural progression of their relationship as Hiccup matures. They see the change as a more realistic portrayal of a bond evolving over time. Comments like "[insert positive comment example]" are common.

• Examples of negative fan comments and their reasoning: However, many fans strongly disagree. They feel the change diminishes the unique bond between Hiccup and Toothless, removing the core element of mutual respect and friendship that defined their relationship in the original. Negative feedback often takes the form of comments like "[insert negative comment example]".

• Mention any petitions or organized online discussions regarding the change: The intensity of the debate is evident in the several online petitions and dedicated forum threads devoted to discussing and debating the merits and drawbacks of the altered relationship. These discussions are highly valuable in understanding the depth of the fan reaction.

The Creative Rationale: Why the Change Was Made (Speculation and Analysis)

Understanding the How to Train Your Dragon Remake Rationale requires careful speculation and analysis. While official statements from the filmmakers might be sparse, we can attempt to unravel the potential reasons behind this creative choice.

• Possible reasons for the change, e.g., modernizing the narrative, improving pacing, aligning with current animation trends: The shift may be an attempt to modernize the narrative, reflecting current societal values and expectations about relationships. It could also be a strategy to improve pacing or align the storytelling with current animation trends.

• Discussion of the filmmakers' potential goals: Perhaps the filmmakers aimed to create a more emotionally resonant, even slightly melancholic, portrayal of a bond evolving with age. This could have been a conscious artistic decision.

• Consideration of the target audience for the remake: The remake may also cater to a broader audience, including those unfamiliar with the original trilogy. This broader appeal might have influenced the creative choices, favoring a more universally understandable narrative arc.

The Long-Term Impact: Will it Affect the Franchise?

The long-term impact of this creative decision on the How to Train Your Dragon Franchise Future remains to be seen. However, it’s undeniable that this change could have significant repercussions.

• Potential impact on merchandise and future adaptations: The altered dynamic might necessitate changes in future merchandise and adaptations, potentially altering the marketing and promotional strategies employed by the franchise.

• Analysis of the change's effect on the overall narrative arc of the franchise: Depending on future installments, this subtle alteration to the core relationship could fundamentally change the overarching story and tone of the entire franchise.

• Discussion on how the reaction might influence future creative decisions within the franchise: The intense fan reaction might force the franchise to reassess their creative choices for future projects, ensuring they take fan feedback more seriously in their decision-making process. This will ultimately shape the future of the How to Train Your Dragon universe.

Conclusion

This article explored the almost controversial decision to alter the Hiccup and Toothless relationship in the How to Train Your Dragon remake. We examined the specific change, the widely varied fan reactions, potential motivations behind the alteration, and its possible long-term effects on the franchise. The debate highlights the deep emotional connection fans have with these characters and the significant impact even subtle changes can have on a beloved story.

What are your thoughts on this almost controversial decision in the How to Train Your Dragon remake? Share your opinions and analysis in the comments below! Let's discuss the future of the How to Train Your Dragon franchise and the impact of this significant change. Join the conversation and let us know what you think about this controversial How to Train Your Dragon remake choice.